Why Smoke Alarm Failures Trigger Legal Issues
Smoke alarms must meet high safety standards. Manufacturers are responsible for designing and producing devices that reliably detect smoke or fire, provide an alert, and allow occupants time to react. When a smoke alarm is defective—whether because of design errors, manufacturing flaws, or inadequate warnings—injured parties may have grounds for a product liability claim. In legal terms, these claims often fall into one of three categories: design defect (the alarm was fundamentally unsafe), manufacturing defect (a specific unit deviated from the intended safe design), or failure to warn (insufficient instructions or hazard disclosures).
Smoke and carbon monoxide alarms are critical tools at home and the workplace to minimize fire risks and subsequent severe injuries and death. According to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), three of every five home fire deaths result from fires in homes with no smoke alarms or no working smoke alarms.
The death rate per 100 reported home fires is more than twice as high in homes that do not have any working smoke alarms compared to the rate in homes with working smoke alarms.
Smoke alarms and carbon monoxide sensors provide an early warning, giving people additional escape time. Product defects often cause a smoke alarm failure or do not correctly detect a fire. Carbon monoxide and smoke detectors can malfunction due to poor design, poor materials, or due to lack of battery power.
Problems can also arise when detectors are not installed correctly by homeowners, developers or landlords. Terrible burn injuries and death can result from such unfortunate incidents.
Joe Lyon is a highly-rated product liability attorney and defective smoke alarm lawyer representing plaintiffs nationwide in a wide variety of consumer product liability and preventable injury cases.
Defective Smoke Alarms: Landlords & Manufacturers Liable
If a smoke detector is defective and malfunctions, and leads to injuries or deaths, the manufacturer can be held liable for producing, marketing and selling a faulty device. Others may also be responsible when alarms or detectors do not function as intended.
Building contractors, for example, are required to follow federal building codes, and if the proper alarms are not installed or maintained, they may be held liable. Homebuilders have also been known to cut corners and fail to provide adequate training to employees who install smoke detectors and fire alarm systems.
A claim can be filed if it can be proved that a contractor, landlord, builder, or manufacturer provided defective smoke alarms. Responsible parties can be held legally accountable and made to pay financially for the damages they caused.
Recent Recalls of Smoke Alarms
Several recent recalls highlight how even life-safety products sometimes fail to perform:
-
In January 2025, about 328,000 “Samurai” mini smoke-alarms (model SM1) sold through HSN were recalled after it was found that the alarm could fail to detect smoke and therefore not alert users.
-
In June 2025, approximately 50,000 combination smoke and carbon-monoxide detectors (model 51000-600) sold by one company were recalled because the unit might not alert consumers in the event of fire or carbon monoxide exposure.
-
In May 2024, nearly 6,800 detectors from a brand known as CHZHVAN (model JKD-512) were recalled after reports that the alarms could fail to activate when smoke was present.
Defective Kiddie Smoke Alarms Recalled
In March 2018, Kiddie issued a product recall for almost 500,000 units of PI2010 and PI9010 smoke alarms due to a manufacturing defect that inhibits their ability to detect smoke.
The United States Consumer Product Safety Commission announced the recall of the product, which was sold Menards, The Home Depot, Walmart and other department, home and hardware stores nationwide and online at Amazon.com, ShopKidde.com and other websites.
Other recalls of smoke and carbon monoxide detectors have been issued in recent years. The manufacturers of such important products has a duty to see that consumers are protected or they may be liable for the damages and injuries that result.
It is important to a case to preserve all detection systems involved in a fire accident. Following a fire alarm failure, the Lyon Firm can hire a team of investigators and experts to inspect the devices and preserve crucial evidence.
Detection alarms can be inspected even when damaged or burned to determine how the system was designed and installed. After a thorough investigation, it may be possible to file lawsuits against a manufacturer or contractor for negligence and product liability.
